Scope of Investigation Into Unnecessary Hip Surgeries on Children Extended
Locations
In April of this year, it first came to the public's attention that there was an ongoing investigation into whether hundreds of children may have undergone unnecessary and invasive surgeries for hip dysplasia between 2021 and 2023. Hip dysplasia is a condition where the hip joint doesn't develop properly, leading to instability, discomfort, and potential long-term complications.
Children's Health Ireland 2021 – 2023 Review:
This independent review commissioned by Children’s Health Ireland (CHI) was said to have already flagged 561 cases for independent review and it is believed that a number of children underwent unnecessary hip surgeries at two Dublin hospitals since 2021. 79% of surgeries at Cappagh Hospital and 60% at Temple Street Hospital did not meet proper surgical criteria. Most upsetting was the suggestion that some procedures may have been done for financial gain. This alarming finding was presented in the Dáil after whistleblowers raised concerns about surgeries performed on children aged one to seven without medical necessity.
The potential harm to children who underwent these procedures is substantial — many endured painful recoveries, extended time off school, and physical discomfort at a formative stage in life. Families also faced emotional distress and financial burdens, all while trying to support their child through major surgery they may never have needed.
Audit Extended:
It was feared that this review was only scratching the surface and that has unfortunately proved to be the case. Yesterday's revelations confirm that unnecessary surgeries on children may have been occurring for as far back as 15 years ago. Families affected are receiving letters about operations performed on their children, some of whom are now adults, raising renewed concerns about medical negligence and a lack of transparency from healthcare authorities.
The clinical audit is in its final stages. There is, as yet, no timeline for when the full report will be published.
Parents of children who have undergone hip surgery over the last decade and more, are now faced with an uncertain wait to understand whether or not their child is one of those identified in the audit as being the subject of an unnecessary procedure. It is of utmost importance that this investigation by Children's Health Ireland is concluded promptly, and that those impacted are given the full facts about what happened, and how it affects their loved one. It is understood that some families have already received clinical confirmation that their children’s surgeries were not needed.
Legal Considerations for Affected Families:
For families impacted by potential medical negligence, this situation raises serious legal questions:
- Were parents fully informed about the necessity and risks of these surgeries?
- Did hospitals follow best practices, or were children subjected to unnecessary procedures?
- How will these surgeries affect the children’s health and mobility in the short, medium and long-term future?
More information is available here.
Our team of expert medical negligence solicitors can help you understand whether or not you or a loved one were subjected to unnecessary hip surgery and seek the accountability and compensation you deserve.